I am an amateur cameraman and have been working around codecs for the last 6 years. I compared WMV-HD, H.264, DivX-HD and XviD-HD (profile) on my Sony HDR-FX1 shootings. My result: H.264 best by far, but you gotta work out the best codec settings, then DivX-HD, same thing, then XviD-HD (couldn't fit the proper settings to work as I needed) and last WMV-HD (you need quite higher bitrates for the same quality as the mentioned or you see aberations and macroblock artifacts). Because the main point has always been reducing size of MPEG-2/HD TS stream onto something with as little quality drop as possible yet much smaller, I will work with H.264 HD custom profile, until something better comes up. My setting is 1440x1080i (4:3) pixel AR 1:1, variable bitrate round 4.5 Mb, keyframe boost 60%, B-frame reduction 40%, bitrate variability 40%, automatic quantizers 1-51 at step-by-4, spatial encoding, 2-3 unbiased B-frames, all partitions and transforms, adaptive weighted biprediction, slight deblocking, and no CABAC (it is troublesome when combining files and editing too). At these settings I get best results with the same bitrate of all mentioned. Try it out and see.
Now that we've thrown 'em off the trail, use the form below to get in touch with the people at Engadget. Please fill in all of the required fields because they're required.
I am an amateur cameraman and have been working around codecs for the last 6 years. I compared WMV-HD, H.264, DivX-HD and XviD-HD (profile) on my Sony HDR-FX1 shootings. My result: H.264 best by far, but you gotta work out the best codec settings, then DivX-HD, same thing, then XviD-HD (couldn't fit the proper settings to work as I needed) and last WMV-HD (you need quite higher bitrates for the same quality as the mentioned or you see aberations and macroblock artifacts). Because the main point has always been reducing size of MPEG-2/HD TS stream onto something with as little quality drop as possible yet much smaller, I will work with H.264 HD custom profile, until something better comes up. My setting is 1440x1080i (4:3) pixel AR 1:1, variable bitrate round 4.5 Mb, keyframe boost 60%, B-frame reduction 40%, bitrate variability 40%, automatic quantizers 1-51 at step-by-4, spatial encoding, 2-3 unbiased B-frames, all partitions and transforms, adaptive weighted biprediction, slight deblocking, and no CABAC (it is troublesome when combining files and editing too).
At these settings I get best results with the same bitrate of all mentioned. Try it out and see.