Ask Engadget HD: Is switching from cable to satellite worth it?
By Darren Murph 
posted Apr 30th 2008 12:00PM
posted Apr 30th 2008 12:00PM
"Now that DirecTV is almost at 100 national HD channels, I'm this close to cutting my cable off and making the switch. However, I'm terrified of hidden installation costs (fishing cables, etc.), punching all sorts of new holes in my home, locking myself into a contract and having to pay a non-discounted rate to keep my cable internet around without bundled HD service. There seems to be so many drawbacks to getting a dish -- is it really worth it?"
We have no doubts that many of you have indeed pulled the trigger in a similar situation, and we're equally sure that a large chunk of you have decided to play it safe and stick with fewer HD channels (and fewer battle scars on your siding). We can definitely see this one getting heated, but make sure you speak your mind on the matter in comments below.
[Image courtesy of Flickr]
Got a burning question that you'd love to toss out for Engadget HD (or its readers) to take a look at? Tired of Google's blank stares when you ask for real-world experiences? Hit us up at ask at engadgethd dawt com and keep an eye on this space -- your inquiry could be next.
If your home is pre-wired for cable, the installer will tap into those existing lines. The new HD dishes are no longer 18 inches unfortunately.
If you need a 2-tuner DVR, they'll run an extra cable to those boxes.
Actually, they are starting to utilize something called SWM (Single Wire Multiswitch) technology that allows them to stack multiple signals on a single cable. You run one wire to the SWM port on your HR20/21 and it can provide signal to both tuners. You wont need the second wire run anymore.
My biggest issue with satellite is the loss of the signal every time it snows or rains heavily. If it weren't for this, I'd recommend it with whole heart.
I live in Colorado, and Have DirecTV. Suprisingly if you have your dish properly secured to your house, then you should not have any signal loss. My dish has Weatherd 3 Blizzards, Countless Hail storms, and Apocalyptic weather changes and through all this I only lost signal once when a tree fell on my house.
I live in Colorado, and Have DirecTV. Suprisingly if you have your dish properly secured to your house, then you should not have any signal loss. My dish has Weatherd 3 Blizzards, Countless Hail storms, and Apocalyptic weather changes and through all this I only lost signal once when a tree fell on my house.
Rain fade? I've had DirecTV since 1997 in two houses-- one in Florida (installed myself) and one in Chicago (DirecTV installed). I get rain fade maybe once every six weeks, and then for 1-2 minutes maximum. We just had a record-setting winter in Chicago and I think I had fade maybe twice all winter.
I have several neighbors who use Dish and they're all happy as well.
In contrast, I've got two neighbors who have Comcast. One has a Comcast truck outside his house every two weeks with problems. The other loved Comcast at first (switched from Dish) as he loved VOD, but now is saying that he's going back to satellite as he says that the VOD stuff rarely changes and his cable goes out weekly for hours at a time.
I have HD through DirecTV and I am very disappointed. When I signed up for the service in 2006 I was informed that over 75 channels would be available in HD by the end of the year. Now, that they claim over 100 channels I get about 6 HD channels. I called their customer service dept and was informed that most HD channels were not in my plan, and that the 100 channel claim includes many channels that are pay-per-view or feature "some HD content". So basically I have paid $85 per month for two years to watch Planet Earth once in HD, and a crap load of upscaled Law & Order episodes on TNT HD. I could have bought a Blu-ray player several times over to go with my 8-at-a-time Netflix account. I suggest a lot of research before committing to anything.
Nearly everything I watch on DirecTV is in HD. And I don't get any premium channels. So I'm a bit confused by your "6 HD channels" statement.
With the $10 a month HD package at DirecTV you will be able to see the HD version of any standard def station that you have in your package (plus HDNet). If you are not seeing these stations, it is likely that you have old hardware that can only decode MPEG2. The newer stations are all MPEG4. A newer set top box/DVR should get you going.
Dude, I think its clearly your fault here! I bet you havenet upgraded to the new dish and Mpeg4 receivers have you?!!! Even with the basic HD package you get at least 45 channels in HD. You need to call D* fast and get the free upgrade!
For the price your paying you should have more than 6 channels. Do you have the 5LNB dish? If you were installed in 2006, It wouldn't have been it unless you upgraded recently.
Thanks for all your comments!
I have had an an HR-20 receiver and a 5LNB dish since last May, but when I got the upgrade the BBC converter was not installed. I can't believe I paid for HD service for this long without realizing something was terribly wrong. I argued about th crappy my HD service to the Directv customer service department a month ago and the representative made no mention of the converter. The rep also did not find it strange that I was only getting six HD channels. I am glad this topic came up on Engadget HD, and again THANKS!
Glad you figured it out. I upgraded to HD with Directv in March and LOVE it. 95% of the channels I watch are in HD. I am VERY happy with my Directv service.
Am I missing something? I just signed up for Directv here in Las Vegas and they had to run tons of cable for our 2DVRs and 1 HD DVR. I was charged nothing for installation and the standard prices on their website for the boxes.
If you don't feel comfortable with installers adding an extra line and you're going for DirecTV, make sure you pickup a Single Line Multi Switch. That will let you run both tuners off of a single coax cable.
Me? I'm really enjoying my HR-21. I miss my HD DirecTiVo, but am loving all the HD that it was never going to get. Now all I need to do is add a 1TB drive and I'll be good.
Left Time Warner for DirecTV on 02.25.08 and never looked back. The reception is stunning and no rain fade to date. Besides Time Warner's limited HD offering, I was unable to watch a complete HD program without the pixels and the sound breaking up. . . . . this is under a clear sky. Their negative claims against DirecTV are not warranted.
DirecTV is the only way to watch HD! To hell with bundles.
I recently switched from WOW Cable to Dish Network. I was paying WOW roughly $80 for digital cable, a DVR, and their "HD package". I put that in quotes because at 20-some channels, you can hardly call it a package. But I did like the HD channels. They ended up being all I watched. Which meant I was paying $80 for about 20 channels that I watched, and 250-some that I didn't.
I instead opted to switch to Dish Network and their DishHD package, which is all of their national HD channels, for $29/mo. So I now pay about $40/mo (paid a bit extra to include locals) for 60-some channels that I love instead of $80 for a few hundred channels that I don't.
I now get nothing but HD channels and I love it. Have had zero problems with the satellite itself. My locals are in standard def, but I pick them up in HD over-the-air. Dish has been steadily rolling out locals in HD for awhile now, so I have high hopes that they'll hit my market soon enough.
I have the DishHD package with the 200 or so channel package, as well as local networks. My friends typically pay about $20 less per month, but with both DishHD and locals over a $30 set-top Phillips antenna, I have around 40 HD channels. I don't figure that's too bad, and being in a rural area, it beats the hell out of "expanded cable" with no current plans for digital/HD service. For what it's worth, I'm picking up 6 local stations from towers as far as 120MI (fair land) off a 40db set-top antenna :) The quality is about on par with iTunesHD and XBox Live HD rentals. I don't have a DVR, so I can't justify to the quality of the buffered video.
I'm in the same situation....I am a soon to be married man as well as recent college grad with an entry level office job and we are going to forgo cable or dish for a while and pick up the few local channels over the air. However, I've been trying to lure my fiance into considering dish networks $30/month all HD package. I currently have Comcast's HD package where I live now with my 3 college buddies, but $73month split 3 ways is much easier to swaller with roommates. I think we may end up going with Dish, but my biggest fear?
Year long contracts. Being that we will live in an apartment for only a year or two, I don't want to get dish halfway into my lease, and then have to get dinged the huge cancellation fee just because we're moving. I dunno... either way, it's Verizon's DSL for now (3/768 for 34.99) and then we'll go from there.
You may want to check out the DishMover program. This way you won't have to pay a termination fee, as long as you continue to use Dish at your new location whenever you move. I think it's something like if you sign up for 2 years, they'll install the equipment in your new home for free (you leave the actual Dish at your old location and they just come and get it and take your receiver with you.) I don't know all of the details, but they show DishMover ads a lot on the Dish Channels, and I'm sure there's more info at their website.
I've been using Dish for almost 8 years now. Recently upgraded to HD package on top of the 200+ channel & locals package. I would never go back to cable. Now Verizon's FiOS TV on the other hand, I might have to seriously consider....
I got my DirecTV from costco when I purchased a new HDTV so they threw in about $250 in rebates and costco cash so it was worth it. Plus Suddenlink doesn't have shit for HD channels. The only drawback is that I'm in the boonies in northern Cali and I can't get HD locals which suck when the Lakers play on ABC.
Who gives a damn about the stupid lakers!!!!
I went from TWC to Dish HD. Way more selection, WAY better picture quality and better DVR.
Only thing I don't like about it, bad weather. When there is a huge rain storm or gale force winds (lately) my service goes out. Of course, you don't have that with cable.
But I can deal with it and watch recorded shows on my DVR.
You can switch to Dish without contract and just pay monthly, you just dont get their promotion which saves you $20 for six months.....I'd personally rather have the freedom of going back to cable so I opted to waive the promotion and not get stuck in a 2year contract....its working out great..
I don't think it's worth it because of DTV's customer service. They will rope you into a commitment for 2 years, and keep extending it, just for "leasing" a receiver that you can never own. The billing is awful and is rising in cost faster than cable.
Overall, my DTV experience was horrible and they wound up costing far more than cable.
I switched to DirecTV years ago and have never regretted it. Being an HD snob (I don't watch it if it is not in HD!) I love having so many HD stations.
I do 99% of my TV watching in one room, so the installation was not really an issue for me. I have 4 lines from my dish and one from my antenna. Your siding will get over a few extra lines run in :)
I can't speak for dish, but the DirecTV service is very dependable, outside of the occasional outage due to bad weather. I have had several different cable providers over the years and on more than one occasion experienced extended cable outages (1+ day each occurance). I have never experienced anything of the sort with DirecTV.
I still have cable for my internet service, but I feel that I get more bang for my buck having so many HD stations (and in my area all around cheaper pricing compared to my local cable company) that it makes up for the lost discount on the cable internet.
I switched and I am glad. Time Warner Cable is too far behind. I now get to enjoy Battlestar Galactica in HD on DirecTV. I did my own fishing of the walls and directed the installation. Anytime the installer said that would cost extra, I did it myself and worked with him. The result is the install went my way and didn't cost me anything extra....the guy wanted to drill a hole in my laminate floor in the living room. I told him absolutely not and that we needed to go thru the actic. That's when he laid the $9.95 per fished wall outlet on me and then I told him I would do that part and he had no choice but to agree to it...
$9.95?! The guy at my house dropped $45/wall on me! I told him no way in hell, seeing as both my father and brother are electricians. I guess when I told I wasn't going to pay to drop wires down the wall, he enterpretted that as not running any wires for the two rooms I was adding and instead measuring out the approximate amount of cable it would take, connect one end othe lines to the dish and leave them hanging off the roof for me to finish. This after he showed up 4 hours later than the 8-12 window they told me.
To top it all off, the "installation" he did in March, didn't work in May when the trees came in. So we had to moved the dish to the middle of the house and had to call for someone to come out to align the dish. Again, got the 8-12 window, and at 1:30 I had to go somewhere and still noone was to be found. DirecTV's installers are the biggest joke/hacks out there.
My brother used to install satellite for Dish & DirecTV. Since they were contracted out, they could charge whatever they wanted for running extra cable or installing a phone jack. It all depends on the company that is contracted out to do the installation in your area.
I just made the switch from cable to sat. a few weeks ago. I debated for quite some time over the issue for some of the same reasons you mentioned. One in particular was being held to a contract. Not that I am afraid of commitment or anything, it was just easier having cable and being able to drop it at any time. I am, however, very glad I made the switch. With the new user discounted rates (I know...... the rates jump back up after a year) I am getting way more for a minimal difference in price. Installation was truly free I have had no problems thus far.
I live in FL and in 7 years I've only signal a total of about 10 minutes. If your dish is aimed properly, this is not an issue.
I made the switch 1 month ago from cable to Direct TV. So far, so good. I sometimes get random pixel streaks (lasting < 2sec) but that's part of getting a satellite signal compared to hard wired cable. HD channels look good. I don't like the stretch-o-vision channels (USA-HD, TNT-HD, etc..) but for the most part, it was a good move.
I have the HR21-100 DVR and it has it's bugs but that's why you should get on dbstalk forums. Users helping other users. It's a great move that really helps.
As far as rain interrupting the signal, hasn't happened yet and it has rained quite a few times. It's doesn't snow in South Texas so not sure about that one.
I really didn't have many complaints about Time Warner when I had them. The DVR box was terrible but the menu prompts had much faster reaction times compared to Directv. The Directv menu is slow but I'm getting used to it. The DVR is slowly getting better. It's not TiVo by any means but it will do.
Installation was free, cables and everything else was free. Dbstalk forums have great guides on how to go about getting installation along with a checklist. It really helps!!!!!
I personally left TWC for DirecTV in early March b/c of the crappy HD package TWC had in northeast wisconsin. Add to the fact the ability to get the Mega March Madness and NFL Ticket packages made it a no brainer for me, despite the fact I'm now paying about $20 extra.
Not having HD Tivo on satellite is a deal-breaker for me.
I still don't understand why we don't have a USB dongle for Dish and DirecTV when they're coming for switched digital video.
I wish they would all just make a USB dongle so that we could use whatever DVR we wanted.
I used to feel this way. But after having DirectTV HD DVR's for about 6 months now, I find them to be much better, in almost every way. The number one reason? They are faster, more responsive. I don't miss TiVo even a little bit. I can't honestly think of one thing that the TiVo box did better.
I started with DirecTV back in November 2007. I must say it is awesome! I had Dish Network for 2 years at our old house but when we moved and I got a new HDTV we decided to switch to DirecTV. Our other option was Comcast which is horrible in my neighborhood. So I opted for Verizon FIOS internet. Anyway with that being said everything is great and the HD is awesome over DirecTV. Our service has only gone out once during a really heavy rain. The outage was only for a few minutes. There is no way I would go back to cable. The technology from DirecTV is top notch. Make sure you check out DBStalk for the latest info on both DirecTV and Dish.
If you don't mind the dish on your house, it's definitely worth it... More HD channels, plus absolutely zero analog stuff like you get with even digital cable (don't let the cable company fool you). If all the rooms in your house are wired already, then no worries about fishing new wires--the dish feed can use existing cable. The phone carriers often offer their own bundle package to compete with the cable cos. For instance AT&T here in the Southeast US can bundle Dish network, DSL internet, home phone, long distance, and wireless on one bill at a significant discount, plus they pay significant rebates when switching. I got over $250 back when I switched.
I switched from TWC to DTV back in November and definitely don't regret it. The installers were great. They were there for 2 hours putting it in exactly how I wanted it. Never complained and didn't charge me a dime. The picture quality and channel selection are much better than TWC ever was. I used to get the "digital blocks" all the time with cable, now there's none of that. Also, I have never lost signal for any reason and we've had some nasty snow/rain storms since I got it that I was sure would knock out the signal. Even after all this, my bill is still $30 less than what I was quoted for a comparable HD package from TWC. Also, DTV's customer service is much better. They're friendly, helpful, and, best of all, don't leave you waiting on hold for an hour every time you call.
I was worried about the switch, but I recommend it to everyone now.
In November 2007 I dropped comcast for DirecTV. I have no regrets. I pay about the same amount of money but get far more HD channels. The picture quality of the HD channels is noticeably superior to what I was getting from Comcast in Houston.
I agree with the comment about getting a Single Wire Multiswitch...otherwise they have to run TWO lines to each room that has a DVR.
Be aware that some hidden discounts with your current cable/internet service might disappear when you switch. When I switched from Comcast to DirecTV, my comcast Internet price increased $15/month. They do this as a way to reduce the savings from satellite TV. Your provider may be different.
Good luck with it, I wouldn't go back to comcast for anything!
I switched from Comcast to Direct TV two years ago and am so happy I did. Comcast got more and more inflexible when it came to pricing and deals. There used to be a time when as an existing customer you could still get the deal that was going on for pricing, when that stopped I did my research and went with Direct TV.
I was also concerned with wiring but Dtv said they used the existing Comcast wires from the front of the house to connect to the Direct TV dish in back, which my landlord liked. They were able to put the 5 Lnb dish in the back, bolted to molding on house, not on roof and were able to run some additional lines that Comcast didn't have without drilling inside the house. The only downside is that the lines they ran are basically draped over the roof of the house but they said they'll weather the San Francisco climate, we'll see.
The installation was free and mostly painless. I had to slow down the techs, there were four of them in the house and on top of the house, so that I knew what they were doing and so I could tell the landlord, who lives below us, unfortunately. They did a great job. They've only come out one more time when we upgraded one of the receivers to a Dtv DVR receiver, for spare room.
As for the service itself, I've been EXTREMELY happy with their customer service and how easy it is to get an operator, granted they don't always know everything but have always been nice and accomodating. The quality of HD is fine, but sometimes lags on fast moving sports events but overall is great and the amount of channels is the BEST. I pretty much only watch HD, occasionally will watch a show in SD but try not to.
The other downside is that I have three Tivos and they're not compatible with my two HD televisions, so I've had to do some mickeymousing and accept watching those shows in SD or transferring to the SD tv in the house, so it looks normal.
I've recommended Direct TV to all of my friends, have one switching next month from Comcast to Direct TV. I also tried to convince my parents but they already have Dish and have decided to stick with them and add HD, now that they have an HD TV.
For the moment, I have no intentions of switching from Direct TV but then again, we're limited here in San Francisco. The only other really competitive service is Comcast. I wish there were more options, with the same amount of service, especially since Dtv raised their rates on us last month but it's still pretty fair.
I have had DirecTV for 8 years and just recently made the switch DirectTV HD. I have never had a problem besides the normal loss of signal during heavy rain storms. But when I started the process to change to HD it create a weekend long headache. First it took me 3 DirectTV reps just before they would even give me a discount for changing over to HD. I guess there is no reason to be a valued customer. Once I got what I felt was a good deal (Replacement of my Standard DVR to HD DVR and a $10 credit each month for the next 12 months and there woould be a $112 extra charge on my next bill). So the install was scheduled for the upcoming weekend. I was scheduled for the install between 1 and 4. The install guy shows up 5:30 on Saturday. He spends two hours setting up the Satellite and hooks up the HD DVR. Then tells me the HD DVR is bad. He will have to come back Monday. He returns Monday at 1:30. Only after I made several calls to DirecTV trying to get a time when he would return. Well to finish up I have HD and love it. DirecTV didn't charge me the extra $112 on my next bill and I am still getting the $10 credit. So all have to say is go with DirecTV and push your way thru DirecTV Customer Service Reps until someone gives away the farm.
Never choose DirecTV. Let me explain.
Installer came to install lines for a 4 HD DVR setup. Drilled a hole in our internal sprinkler system while dropping lines down from the attic, and ruined a significant portion of the house. A $100k plus, 3 month tear-down/buildout was required, not to mention the $50k in personal losses. The installer claimed responsibility, his supervisor was fired for allowing him to do so, and DTV only paid back 70% of the claim (even after admitting their guilt), even after hard-line subrogating.
3 months of my life were wasted in a pre-furnished apartment waiting for the re-construction, and all the while DTV charged us for the service, even after suspending the account. They offered us nothing for our inconvenience, we logged close to 50 phone calls and several hours of phone time climbing the food chain for further compensation, claims with the BBB, and all avenues we could pursue for any admission of guilt or apology. None was ever received, and I will have a permanent blemish on all further insurance premiums from the claims induced. My rentor's insurance has quadrupled, and I would not qualify for homeowner's insurance at any less of a premium of 5% of the value of my house yearly due to the claim. Now that's what I call "customer service".
Avoid DirecTV like the PLAGUE. They'll kick you in the stomach, lash you with a belt while you're down, and spit in your face to finish the job.
But I don't have an internal sprinkler system.
I would switch from time warner to direct tv if they offered local channels in HD in my area, most of the HD TV that I watch is from the major networks.
It's worth it if you can do the install yourself. The only thing I would ask DirecTv to do for you is send someone out to align the dish. Other than that, there rest of their install work is a complete hack job.
We can SURE to that! We made one of the biggest mistakes las summer & tried DIRECT TV, 8 hrs. later dish aimed at a tree (great for recep,)ruined carpet to pt. of having to be replaced, The installer kept drilling holes down thru the floor, ruining ceiling downstairs, then we are still out out early contract withdrawl, canceled within 24hrs, whichch is almost $300. Haven't received refund from Quest as was bundle.
Went back to Comcast & even got a discount! Gotta love them!
One thing I keep trying to figure out is building your own DVR with Satellite. Unless the box has firewire you just can't do it...yet.
That is the main thing keeping me from switching.
Ditching Comcast for Dish Network was the greatest move I made. I wish I had done it a year sooner!